Wednesday 17 February 2016

To 'tick' or not to 'tick', that is the question



Two birds that I have seen locally this year have been the Mandarin duck at Eye Green Nature Reserve and the Barnacle Goose, one at Ferry Meadows CP and another one today at Baston and Langtoft Gravel Pits. The Mandarin has been 'ticked', despite being rather tame and coming to bread given by the locals, the reason being that there are four of these birds present and have bred here for the past two years (according to said locals). The two geese are a different matter;the one at Ferry Meadows has been assumed to be a 'wild' bird, I don't know why, it just has, but the one at BLGP is a 'feral' bird, a bird that has been presumed to have escaped from some collection or other and therefore cannot be counted. This bird has been present in the area for a few years now and hangs around with the local Greylags, it has become wild. I am only noting the differences in attitude towards birds of varying breed, but mostly wildfowl because it befuddles my brain. We 'tick' Pheasant, but the vast majority of the birds that we see have been released into the wild for shooting purposes, surely this is a bird that is a very questionable 'tick', the same goes for Red-legged Partridge.

Wildfowl seem to have different rules though. If a bird escapes from a wildfowl collection and goes on to survive in the wild for a number of years it will always be thought of as 'feral'. The Hooded Merganser that is present at Radipole Lake in Dorset has been thought of as an escapee, then accepted as a wild bird and now is being classed as an escapee again. The same goes for Bufflehead. A very rare 'wild' bird here and every bird that is seen in the wild in the UK has to pass the 'escapee' tag before a 'twitch' is on the cards. Some of you may remember a few years back a Richardson's Canada Goose that was present on the north Norfolk coast for a while. Myself and my friend Chris went to see this bird along with quite a few other people, but this goose was classed as an escapee by some and a wild bird by others. I don't know if it will get accepted as a wild bird and so therefore I haven't 'ticked' it, although I know a few people who have.

Drake Hooded Merganser (taken at Slimbridge WWT)

Female Bufflehead (taken at Slimbridge WWT)

Richardson's Canada Goose (taken at Slimbridge WWT)
What we should do is just marvel at the beauty of any bird, whether truly wild or not.

12 comments:

  1. I've always thought that a bird that has the wit to escape and then the resourcefulness to survive must have a bit more about it than some storm-blown no-hoper with a faulty compass that will probably perish in the next day or two - but that's just me!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very true John, although I know some that may disagree with you.
      J

      Delete
  2. I agree - seeing any bird surviving in the wild, whether originally captive or not is a wonderful thing- your photos are beautiful

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Sharon! The wild is truly a beautiful place.
      J

      Delete
  3. It's your list so I think you should include whatever you wish. Great birds to see in any event.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True David. I don't know if I would feel guilty though!
      J

      Delete
  4. Replies
    1. And I probably would be damned by some!
      J

      Delete
  5. If it ain't changed to a post, its free to go where it likes, nobody owns it, then its Wild John.{:))

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I will save that mantra Roy, maybe for another day though.
      J

      Delete
  6. Such a lovely series of birds, John!

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to comment on my humble blog.